Towards predictable periodontal tissue engineering: a bibliometric overview 2005-2025
The regeneration of periodontal tissues, irreversibly destroyed by periodontitis, remains one of the most arduous clinical challenges in general practice and periodontology. While tissue engineering offers solutions based on extracellular matrices, stem cells, and growth factors, the scientific literature on filling materials has become fragmented and plethoric, making it difficult for the practitioner to interpret current technological advances.
This bibliometric study aims to clarify this complexity by mapping research trajectories on periodontal scaffold materials over a twenty-year period (2005–2025). Based on 528 articles indexed in the Web of Science Core Collection, the authors used CiteSpace and VOSviewer tools to analyse publication volumes, international collaborations, and, above all, the thematic evolution of the field. The objective is to highlight the shift in research, moving from fundamental in vitro studies towards clinical translational strategies.
The underlying hypothesis is that current innovation is focusing on multifunctional and intelligent biomaterials — including hydrogels, chitosan, and 3D-printed composites — endowed with antibacterial and immunomodulatory properties. This analysis seeks to identify whether global interdisciplinary collaboration has effectively enabled the transformation of these laboratory concepts into personalised therapeutic tools for the dental practice.
Methodology: Bibliometric analysis
This study is based on a bibliometric methodology aimed at mapping the evolution and trends of research on scaffold materials for periodontal treatment between 2005 and 2025. The sole data source used is the Web of Science Core Collection, selected for its robustness and exhaustive coverage of scientific publications.
The analysis protocol was structured as follows:
- Data selection: The identification of articles was carried out based on targeted queries linking periodontal diseases to scaffold materials, resulting in a final corpus of 528 eligible English-language articles.
- Analysis tools: Data processing was performed via the specialised software CiteSpace and VOSviewer.
- Evaluation parameters: The authors analysed several key indicators: the volume of annual publications, international and institutional collaboration networks, journal co-citation, as well as the evolution of themes via keyword frequency analysis.
The approach allows for a visual and quantitative interpretation of research dynamics, classifying publications by country, authors, and fields of application, ranging from initial fundamental in vitro research to contemporary translational clinical strategies. This synthesis does not include new experimental tests but aggregates and quantifies existing literature over the defined 20-year period.
Dynamics of research on periodontal biomaterials (2005-2025)
This bibliometric analysis, covering 528 articles published in English and extracted from the Web of Science Core Collection, maps the evolution of periodontal regeneration strategies over two decades. The data reveal a marked acceleration in scientific production starting from 2015, with a major concentration of editorial activity: more than 60% of the total volume of publications was generated over the 2020-2024 period.
Geographical distribution and collaborations
China and the United States stand out as the undisputed leaders in terms of publication volume. The analysis of co-citation networks highlights that innovation is now driven by structured international collaborations, mainly articulated around three axes: Europe-United States, Europe-China, and United States-China.
Thematic and technological evolution
The analysis of high-frequency keywords allows for the segmentation of research priorities into three distinct phases:
| Period | Thematic focus |
|---|---|
| Initial (pre-2015) | Basic research, in vitro studies, stem cell differentiation. |
| Intermediate | Clinical applications, bone regeneration, delivery systems. |
| Recent (post-2020) | Functional biomaterials, hydrogels, chitosan, nanocomposites, 3D printing. |
To equip yourself
Delynov products related to this topic:
- Safescraper Twist Curve - Sterile cortical bone scraper - Meta - Pack of 3 - 3987 (Cortical bone harvesting for regeneration)
Delynov Surgery, your supplier of surgical sutures absorbable and non-absorbable, consumables and implant surgery instruments.
The current post-2020 trend marks a shift towards the development of multifunctional materials integrating antibacterial, immunomodulatory, and regenerative properties. Research has thus migrated from a purely experimental in vitro approach towards clinical translational strategies aimed at personalized tissue regeneration.
Towards precision periodontal engineering: bibliometric analysis 2005-2025
A bibliometric analysis covering 528 articles published between 2005 and 2025 highlights a marked acceleration in research on bone substitutes and periodontal scaffolds, with more than 60% of scientific production concentrated in the 2020-2024 period. This peak in activity reflects a paradigm shift: research has gradually moved away from fundamental in vitro studies and basic cell differentiation to focus on translational and clinical regeneration strategies.
The data reveal a major technological mutation. Since 2020, dominant themes include hydrogels, chitosan, nanocomposites, and 3D printing. The objective is no longer just mechanical support, but the integration of multifunctional properties: antibacterial, immunomodulatory, and regenerative. International collaboration, particularly between Europe, the United States, and China, appears to be the essential driver of this innovation. However, this study highlights a persistent fragmentation of clinical data, with research remaining dispersed across numerous materials and manufacturing technologies.
The main limitation of this study lies in its bibliometric nature: while it maps research trends, it does not measure the intrinsic clinical efficacy of the cited materials, limiting itself to the analysis of their popularity and theoretical influence. It does, however, confirm that we are entering the era of personalized "smart scaffolds," capable of responding dynamically to the needs of the injured periodontal site.
Synthesis of research dynamics: 20 years of biomaterials in periodontology
This bibliometric analysis covering 528 articles published between 2005 and 2025 reveals a major acceleration in research from 2015, with more than 60% of the total volume concentrated in the 2020–2024 period. The work has shifted radically, moving away from fundamental in vitro studies to focus on clinical translation strategies using multifunctional biomaterials (hydrogels, nanocomposites, and 3D printing) with antibacterial and immunomodulatory properties.
Concretely, for the practitioner:
- Anticipate therapeutic evolution: The transition towards "smart" and personalised biomaterials confirms that future periodontal management will rely on scaffolds combining mechanical support and active biological signalling.
- Follow emerging standards: The increasing integration of 3D printing and hydrogels in the literature suggests an imminent shift in guided tissue regeneration protocols towards bespoke solutions.
- Clinical caution: While research is moving towards these multifunctional devices, the majority of evidence remains in the development or preclinical phase; therefore, prioritise techniques validated by randomised clinical trials before any adoption in the practice.
Technical glossary
Scaffold materials: Three-dimensional structural supports used in tissue engineering to provide mechanical support and promote the regeneration of periodontal tissues.
Hydrogels: Category of functional biomaterials, identified in recent research, used as matrices for the development of periodontal regeneration strategies.
Chitosan: Natural polymer included in the field of functional biomaterials studied for their ability to integrate antibacterial and immunomodulatory properties into regeneration systems.
Nanocomposites: Advanced materials forming part of scaffold structures, integrated into post-2020 research protocols to optimise clinical outcomes.
3D-printed scaffold materials: Precision manufacturing technology allowing the creation of personalised scaffolds adapted to the needs of periodontal reconstruction.
Tissue engineering: Field of regenerative medicine combining the use of scaffold materials, cell populations, and growth factors to repair tissues destroyed by periodontal disease.
Source
- Original title: Evolution of scaffold materials for periodontal therapeutics over two decades (2005–2025): A bibliometric mapping analysis
- Authors: Yi Lu, Xueyi Li, Ruyiren Hu, Jie Huang, Feifei Zeng, Liqi Wang, Shuo Yang, Yuting Yang, Weilian Sun
- Publication: The Saudi Dental Journal - 2026-09-21
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s44445-026-00235-y
Also read on the Delynov blog
Ivette Maria Santiago Lopez, Lazareth Liz Ortiz Santiago
Optimisation of bone and tissue regeneration: between biological innovations and workflow challenges
Karan Rastogi, Dr. Nitin Tomar, Dr. Roopse, Dr. Mayur Kaushik
Periodontal regeneration: the evolution of bone substitutes and the contribution of growth factors
Information intended for healthcare professionals. This content may contain errors or truncated summaries. We recommend always verifying with the original source article. Delynov disclaims all liability regarding the use of this information. This document is not intended for patients or the general public.



















